← Back to “would you rather”

Why herding cats is better than IT

Everyone in tech has called their job “herding cats.” Turns out the cats have some advantages. Turns out IT has been herding cats all along.

Herding cats

The idiom, taken literally.

28 reasons

  • You can’t herd cats. You also can’t herd developers. At least the cats are upfront about it.
  • Cats sleep 12 to 16 hours a day, and nobody calls it quiet quitting.
  • A cat will sit on your keyboard because it’s warm. Your laptop has never been more useful.
  • A cat walking across the keyboard has sent more emails than some of your coworkers.
  • Cats can recognize their own names. They just choose not to respond. Same as the help desk queue.
  • Cats are most active around dawn and dusk, which is why the outage and the zoomies both start at 5 a.m.
  • A cat knocks things off the table to see what happens. In IT, that’s called chaos engineering, and it has a job title now.
  • Cats hide when they’re sick, so you only find out something’s wrong once it’s serious. Just like production.
  • A closed door is an unacceptable access control. The cat will escalate at full volume until it’s opened.
  • Open the door and the cat won’t go through it. Ticket resolved; user no longer needs it.
  • Adult cats rarely meow at other cats. The meow is mostly for humans. They built an API just for you, and it has one endpoint: food.
  • Cats can be clicker trained. Almost nobody does it, which makes it exactly like your change management process.
  • A purr doesn’t always mean a happy cat. Cats also purr when they’re stressed or hurting. Green dashboards work the same way.
  • Cats can’t taste sweetness. No sugarcoating, ever.
  • Cats spend a big chunk of their waking hours grooming. Finally, a system that maintains itself.
  • Cats usually land on their feet. “Usually” is also the uptime promise of most startups.
  • Catnip only works on some cats, and the sensitivity is inherited. Same with motivational posters.
  • Most adult cats don’t digest milk well. Everything you learned about cats from cartoons was wrong, like everything the sales deck said about the product.
  • Cats are obligate carnivores; they need meat to survive. No amount of stakeholder alignment changes a hard requirement like that.
  • Cats need routine and get stressed by change. No ops team has ever related to an animal more.
  • Slow-blink at a cat and it may slow-blink back. That’s a friendly signal, and more acknowledgment than your ticket got.
  • A cat will sit on exactly the paper you’re reading. It’s always the highest-priority item.
  • Cats skip standup but join every video call, tail first.
  • No 3 a.m. pages. Just a cat sprinting across the bed at 3 a.m. for reasons it won’t put in the postmortem.
  • Cats bring you gifts you didn’t ask for and don’t want. So do vendors at conferences.
  • You don’t own a cat. The cat has admin rights. You have a service account.
  • Cats can’t be fired. They can’t be motivated either.
  • Nobody has ever said managing developers is like milking a goat. Everyone has said it’s like herding cats.

Architecture

For the people who draw the boxes. The cat will sit in one.

5 reasons

  • Every box is a valid deployment target, especially the one that’s slightly too small.
  • Cats always pick the highest point in the room. Finally, someone who understands top-down design.
  • A cat’s design review: push the diagram off the desk and see if it survives the fall.
  • Cats have lived alongside people for thousands of years without a single breaking change to the interface.
  • The cat’s integration pattern is polling. It checks the food bowl every few minutes, whether or not anything changed.

Engineering

For the people who build the thing.

5 reasons

  • Code review by cat: walk across the keyboard, add 400 lines of “jjjjjjj”, approve own pull request.
  • Cats do their own testing. They bat every object on the shelf until something fails.
  • Cats bury their problems. So does every engineering org, but the cat at least uses a designated location.
  • Pair programming: the cat is on the keyboard and you’re watching.
  • Cats nap 12 to 16 hours a day and still hit every deadline they care about. They only care about dinner.

Developers

For the people who write the code at 11 p.m.

5 reasons

  • The cat walked across your terminal and somehow it’s valid Perl.
  • Rubber duck debugging works better with a cat. The cat listens, and it judges.
  • Cats push to main by sitting on the Enter key.
  • Cats don’t read documentation. They try everything and see what falls. That’s also how half of npm works.
  • Cats loved old CRT monitors because the tops were warm. Flat screens were a major regression.

Forward Deployed

For the engineers who live at the customer’s office.

4 reasons

  • Cats are forward deployed by nature. They live in your space and do whatever they want there.
  • First thing on site, the cat claims the customer’s chair.
  • Most cats hate travel and get stressed in carriers and cars. Unlike forward deployed engineers, they’re allowed to say so.
  • The cat’s one-off workaround (sleeping in the printer tray) is now permanent.

Sysadmin

For the people who keep the boxes running.

5 reasons

  • There will be cat fur in every fan, every keyboard, and every rack. You’ll be cleaning it out of hardware for years.
  • Cats reboot with a nap, about a dozen times a day.
  • The cat asleep on the warm UPS is your most reliable temperature sensor.
  • You have sudo. It gets revoked whenever the cat sits on the keyboard.
  • Cats unplug cables for fun. Label your cables. The cat can’t read, but you can.

Operations

For the people holding the pager.

5 reasons

  • Incident: cat knocked over a glass. Cat watched you clean it up. Cat did it again.
  • Postmortem: the cat declined to participate. Root cause: cat.
  • Cats hide illness, so they need regular vet checkups even when everything looks fine. That’s monitoring.
  • The cat’s on-call status: always available, never responding.
  • Change management: move the food bowl six inches and see how many complaints you get.

Blue Team

For the defenders.

5 reasons

  • Cats notice the slightest movement and ignore everything else. Your SOC wishes it could tune alerts that well.
  • A cat’s threat intel: the bird outside the window, monitored for hours, never acted on.
  • Alert fatigue: cats chatter at birds they’ll never catch.
  • The perimeter is every closed door, and the cat tests every one of them hourly.
  • Home defense: sleep through the intrusion, then attack your ankles.

Red Team

For the attackers. The cat is one of you.

6 reasons

  • Cats are natural red teamers. They find every open cabinet, gap, and unlatched door.
  • A cat’s collarbone isn’t attached to its other bones, so it can squeeze through gaps you’d swear were too small. Your firewall rules have the same problem.
  • Privilege escalation: the top of the fridge.
  • Persistence: the cat in the box in the closet you swore you checked.
  • Exfiltration: hair ties, pens, and earbuds, all under the couch.
  • Social engineering: one meow at 5 a.m. and you hand over breakfast.

Pentesting

For the people with a scope document and a deadline.

4 reasons

  • Scope: the counter. The cat was out of scope.
  • Finding: cat on the counter. Remediation: none possible. Risk accepted.
  • Every report ends the same way: the cat got in.
  • The cat retests your fix within ten minutes.

GRC

For the people who have to prove it.

5 reasons

  • The cat has no policy. The cat is the policy.
  • Acceptable use policy: everything belongs to the cat.
  • Risk register: cat. Treatment: accept.
  • The one compliance record that really matters: vaccination records, which many places require for rabies.
  • Audit finding: the cat sat on the evidence.

Sales

For the people who promised it would do that.

5 reasons

  • Cats sell themselves. The internet is the proof.
  • The demo never goes as planned. The cat leaves in the middle of the call.
  • Discovery call: the cat sniffs you for five seconds and decides.
  • Cats don’t do cold outreach. They wait for you to come to them, then act like they don’t care.
  • Closing: you didn’t choose the cat. The cat chose you.

CSTO, CISO and CTO

For the people who explain all of the above to the board.

5 reasons

  • Leading engineers is called herding cats for a reason. Real cats are easier; they don’t expect a career path.
  • Budget request: food, litter, and vet visits. Approved, because the alternative is loud.
  • The cat sat on the board deck.
  • When the board asks “are we secure?”, the honest answer is “the cat got out again.”
  • Cats don’t follow the vision statement. Neither does anyone else, but the cat doesn’t pretend.